Blog

Five myths about online communities

Break free from common myths about online insight communities that might be stopping your organisation from unlocking human-centred insights.

Person in a meeting standing up, smiling and presenting to two other people in the room.
Person in a meeting standing up, smiling and presenting to two other people in the room.

Mark Graham

01 August 2024

4 min read

 

 

This article debunks five common myths about insight communities, exploring their value beyond fast feedback, the range of qualitative and quantitative research they can support, who they can engage and how they can be adapted to different research needs and budgets.

When I first stepped into the world of market research (and let’s not be too specific when that was), online insight communities were a fresh and revolutionary idea. I recall simpler times when clients were absolutely blown away by the idea of always-on access to consumers simply by turning on a computer and logging onto a site on the World Wide Web.

Fast forward to today. Insight communities have become a staple of many leading brands’ research and strategy programs. Insight communities are closed platforms gathering a group of interested and interesting people, from 30 people to 100; this for weeks to months to ongoing. Many insights and market research professionals have worked with communities or are familiar with them. As these communities have gone mainstream, opinions about them have multiplied. Some are fair; others miss the mark entirely. While insight communities aren’t the perfect solution for every challenge, they can deliver significant value when they’re the right fit. In this blog, I’ll tackle some of the most common myths we hear about insight communities and reveal the truth.

Myth #1: Insight communities are only good for fast feedback


This is one of the most common misconceptions we hear. While speed is an advantage of online insight communities, it certainly isn’t the only one.

Insight communities are a powerful and easy way to build empathy with consumers and learn how your target market thinks, feels and lives their lives. Always-on access to consumers provides multiple ways to better understand them and ‘walk a mile’ in their shoes. Take our Consumer Connect programme for Haleon, which brings consumer stories to life, or our work with Anheuser-Busch, where communities fuelled a dynamic innovation trajectory. From designing premium customer experiences to creating products that truly meet people’s needs, the possibilities are endless.

 

Myth #2: Insight communities only collect input from your most vocal consumers


Not if you’re monitoring and resourcing it correctly.

The first way to combat this is through periodic member refreshments, which should be a standard part of every community engagement. This is a process where we bring a new group of people into the community that fit your target audience profile while politely shifting others out of the community. This process ensures you are getting new voices and perspectives into your research program and not relying on the same set of consumers.

The next important piece is moderation. Every insight community should have a dedicated moderator — or team of moderators — to engage community members, keep participation energised and create a safe, respectful space for sharing. Moderators can also encourage members to interact with one another, not just respond to researchers, helping conversations develop while ensuring everyone is heard and not only the loudest voices.

And the last component is cultural context. It is important that moderators not only speak the local language, but also understand the other cultural aspects of their country or region. With their knowledge of the local market situation and business context, they can easily identify with consumers’ values, beliefs and traditions. This ensures that we not only listen to what is said but also comprehend it in the context of consumers’ lived experiences.

 

Myth #3: Insight communities are only suitable for simple methodologies

Far from it. This a two-for-one myth, because we hear it regarding both qualitative and quantitative community inquiries.

So let me start with the qualitative part. There is still a perception from some that insight communities are a fancy word for discussion boards (simple text-based forums). This is not true. Sure, discussion boards are a key piece (and often a powerful one) of the community offering, but modern insight communities have many more ways to capture deep qualitative feedback that include photo sharing, journaling, video and chat functionality.

And when it comes to quantitative, many still equate insight communities with a simple online survey program. But there’s more that can be done. You can use tools that give you in-depth, granular feedback on a static image, a block of copy or video stimuli. If your community sample is high enough, you can use technical quantitative methodologies such as MaxDiff, TURF, Von Westendorp, etc. And depending on your needs, you can even temporarily bring in more members into your community to get a large sample size when robust numbers are needed for a quant exercise.

Our insight communities offer a range of ‘think, feel, do activities’, that include projective techniques, online shopping simulations and ones that that tap into system 1 thinking (e.g., the brain’s fast, automatic and emotional response to stimuli). These off-the-shelf tools make it easy to elevate your community research and get to your objectives in new and exciting ways.

 

Myth #4: Insight communities are only applicable for consumer research

Not really. While most insight community engagements focus on customers, organisations can also create employee and stakeholder communities to gather feedback from people within or connected to the business.

Employee communities can be deployed to keep a pulse on employee morale, test communications and build employee engagement programs. And professional communities – with salespeople, human resource professionals, bankers, etc. – are a great way for service companies to ensure they’re getting valuable feedback from their critical frontline employee.

 

Myth #5: Insight communities are expensive


But they don’t have to be.

If your research objectives are qualitative in nature, your community size can be small, which can save costs. Providing a sample list for your community can also decrease recruitment fees. Setting up a three- or six-month community is another way to manage costs or pilot a new community efficiently, compared to a one-year commitment.

 

At the end of the day, insight communities have gotten unfairly ‘dinged’ in recent years as being limited, cost-prohibitive and frankly, unsexy. But, in reality, that’s simply not the case. At their core, insight communities are about people – understanding them, learning from them, and making decisions that matter. Hopefully, this myth-busting exercise has shown how versatile and valuable these communities can be when tailored to your needs based on your audience, research objectives and budget.

 

FAQs

What is an online insights community?

An online insight community is a dedicated, closed online space that connects a group of pre-profiled people who share a common interest or characteristic. It can run from a week, to couple of weeks or even ongoingly and gives brands ongoing access to the people that matter to them, enabling them to explore how people think, feel and live, build deeper human understanding and collaborate and co-create around business challenges.

What is an online insight community used for?

Online insight communities give organisations ongoing access to consumers or other audiences to better understand how they think, feel and live. They can support a range of objectives, from building consumer empathy and informing innovation to developing customer experiences and products that better meet people’s needs.

Let's connect

Curious what an insights community can do for you?